I was a little surprised to find my name in my local paper, The Brockton Enterprise, a couple of weeks ago. They ran a little blurb about my blog (without ever asking me...) under the title "Prolific Beer Blogger Now Based in Brockton." How did they even find my blog do you ask? Why that would be this (much better written) article that a student up at the University of Maine Orono wrote about my blog. Zach did a pretty good job of hitting the high points of our conversation, and while I don't quite carry a notebook of the beers I have drank, I think he did a good job of capturing how out of control this hobby has gotten... I mean, 500 beers?! Anyhoo, here is Zach's article.
Beer Police gets a sidekick
By Zach Dionne
10/23/08
Cracking a fresh Pumpkinhead and striking the keys on the newest edition of this column, I can say I'm having a good time - with the column, not just the beer. This one's especially exciting as it's not limited to the questionable opinions of my not-quite-veteran palate. This edition focuses on Josh Smith, originally of Mt. Vernon, Maine. He runs a blog at joshsbeerblog.blogspot.com and recently championed more than 500 beers rated and described.
Josh keeps track of every beer he samples in a notebook. He devotes "the bulk" of his purchases to tasting new items. Nearly limitless styles and different brewers keep him interested. "You could drink beer for the rest of your life and not try everything that's out there, you know?"
Yes, I know, but Josh Smith is a hell of a lot closer than me.
He segued into microbrews with Samuel Adams. "Those are pretty drinkable," he said. He now prefers Portland's Shipyard to Boston's Sam Adams. Geary's and Allagash are his choice Maine breweries.
"Geary's has been a longtime favorite. Very balanced, very flavorful - two things I really look for in a beer," Josh said.
Although Josh now lives in Brockton, Mass., he considers Maine home and still cherishes the state's quality brews. "I'm always defending Maine beers down here. They think I kind of boost the scores for Maine beers. It's not just the beer; it's the experience. It's fun sampling local beers."
Bar Harbor Brewing Co.'s Cadillac Mountain Stout, the highest rated beer in Maine, is an esteemed favorite of Josh's. "I like a lot of the dark beers. I think that's something Maine does really well. Maine really has a very good reputation among the beer community."

Josh began brewing his own beer recently and feels the experience gives him new insight into tasting and appreciating other brewers' work. For mainstays, he leans to Cape Ann Fisherman's Brew or Geary's Pale Ale. I put him in the tough hypothetical situation of only having $5 and needing some beer. His answer: "If I'm not going to put the money into a microbrew beer, I'll honestly buy PBR. I find it very easy going down."
Score! The Beer Police and veteran Josh Smith are on the same level in one regard.
We are not on the same tier of succinct tasting vocabulary, however. It takes practice.
"They used some words like 'bready malts' or 'piney hops,' and it's like, really? I don't see that," Josh said of his early days rating and describing beer for pleasure. "At first, I thought people were just kind of full of it." Josh is now fine-tuned to appreciate the subtleties and intrinsic shortcomings of the best and worst brews, the "deeper levels of complexity," in his words.
After the inspirational, craving-inducing interview, I made haste to Burby & Bates to compare taste with him. Consider our takes on the Bar Harbor Cadillac Mountain Stout:
Josh's blog: "Perfect black pour, with tan head of tight bubbles and decent retention. There is a lot going on in this aroma: chocolate malt, free coffee and figs. Taste is of semi-sweet chocolate and roasted coffee รข€¦ Slightly astringent and gently hopped. Silky smooth mouthfeel and fairly heavy."
My notebook: "Creamy, great consistency, terrific taste." Hmm.
"I think a lot of people would look at this and think, 'oh, he's a beer snob.' I'm amazed at how much there is out there. You might not like beer, but there's probably a style you'd think, 'hey, that's pretty good,'" he said.
Josh uses the blog to keep track of what he's tried and to express his personal beer tastes; he doesn't purport to be an authoritative source on the absolute merit of individual beers. When I questioned his rating of Sea Dog's blueberry ale (a sad 3 out of 10), a wildly popular Maine brew, he responded: "My fiancee loves that Blue Paw, and I couldn't be happier. Hey, she's drinking beer."