Updated beer scores

Today I wanted to run through a list of beers that I have already rated but upon drinking them again wanted to change my original ranking. Some of these changes are pretty drastic; no doubt the result of changing tastes as I experience more and more beers. The first of these adjustments may not seem huge, but Allagash White has made the leap from great beer to one of my absolute favorites.

Allagash White
Bottle -- Chris Gasbarro's, Seekonk
cloudy, yellow pour; nice head. i find many belgian beers smell similar, and this is no exception: yeasty, banana, and some mild spices. some faint banana in taste but it is really a gentle citrus flavor that defines this one. i like how spices like coriander and nutmeg are relegated to the background. fizzy mouthfeel, but incredibly easy to drink -- this is the strongest component of the beer. allagash white is the beer that taught me to appreciate belgian styles... high praise.
Original Score: 9
Updated Score: 10

Geary Pale Ale
Bottle -- Winebasket, Brockton
translucent orange color... hoppy aroma... bitterness up-front but balancing malts aren't far behind... smooth. a long time favorite that you will find in my fridge as often as any other beer.
Original Score: 7
Updated Score: 9

Gritty McDuffs Black Fly Stout
Bottle -- Cardoza's, Fall River
dark black pour with foamy tan head. smell and taste of roasted coffee, semi-sweet chocolate, hint of molasses... very carbonated, dry, and a little thin. taste was solid but points definitely deducted for over-carbonation.
Original Score: 5
Updated Score: 6

Gritty McDuffs Original Pub Style
Bottle -- Cardoza's, Fall River
light copper with big sudsy head that disappears quickly. aroma of citrus fruit and buttery popcorn. taste is lemon, bitterness, and a metallic tanginess -- awful. thin mouthfeel, high acidity, flat... not the qualities i look for in a beer. i remembered this beer very fondly but was extremely disappointed upon revisiting it. still love the name and idea though.
Original Score: 8
Updated Score: 4

Sam Adams White Ale
Tap -- Uno's Bar and Grille, Braintree
first of all, this is not a white ale... but once you get past that it is okay. my friends actually really like it, but i am not totally sold. pale pour with fresh, earthy hops emerging. taste has some bitterness, but otherwise pretty light and watery.
Original Score: 3
Updated Score: 4

Shipyard Longfellow Winter Ale
Bottle -- Maine
an american strong ale that they call a hybrid between a porter and a scottish ale. a surprisingly dark pour... molasses, roasted coffee aroma... caramel malts and chocolate come through in taste... well balanced, and smooth enough that you can drink a few of these at a time. especially enjoyable since a case of shipyard was my winnings from a bet with my friend nate...
Original Score: 6
Updated Score: 8

Shipyard Prelude Special Ale
Bottle -- Maine
i mentioned this before, but my dad really won me over on this one. (the mexican food i ate this with the first time through may have caused me to miss some of the interesting stuff going on here...) defined by warming alcohol and levels of complexity -- i bet this would age pretty well. one of my new favorites for a winter seasonal.
Original Score: 7
Updated Score: 9

Stone Coast Knucklebock
Bottle -- Walpole Wine & Spirits
the first rating was a sample at the end of the great international beer festival, so i am going to trust this one instead. lots of malts, as you would expect. pretty good but lacking in something. their beer names are a little cheezy too.
Original Score: 4
Updated Score: 6

Nashoba Valley

A few weeks ago I went on an outing with a few friends to Nashoba Valley Winery in Bolton, MA. I thought it would offer something for everything: apple picking, a winery tour, and even some microbrewed beer. The wine was too fruity and sweet for me, and the crowds were pretty crazy, but I would still recommend it on a fall afternoon. Their beer... not so much. To be fair, they just started brewing and did resist the temptation to put fruit in all their beers too... which is a good start.

Nashoba Valley Bolt 117 Lager
Bottle -- Nashoba Valley Winery, Bolton
sweet grain and some yeast in aroma... taste is very similar, with some sour fruitiness as well. taste isn't the most appealling, but fairly refreshing.
Score: 4

Nashoba Valley Heron Ale
Bottle -- Nashoba Valley Winery, Bolton
an american pale ale, but this seems much more like an english pale ale to me. buttery aroma, few hops, and a rather weak, muddled taste.
Score: 5

Nashoba Valley Oaktoberfest
Bottle -- Nashoba Valley Winery, Bolton
flavorless malts... a little oakey i guess. a one-dimensional beer. kind of clever name.
Score: 4

Nashoba Valley Wattaquadoc Wheat
Bottle -- Nashoba Valley Winery, Bolton
nose, taste: it's mostly wheat with some cloves and spices. effervescent mouthfeel. very light and surprisingly good.
Score: 6

New Brewers

You probably have noticed the list of "Bottle Stores" on the left side of this page. To drink 500 different beers you have to visit a few liquor stores... and I have found some really good ones in my travels. My favorite stores usually have a large selection of craft beers from a range of domestic brewers. I really like it when you can purchase singles. And reasonable prices are a good thing too.

One of the most recent additions to the list is Luke's Liquors in Rockland. This may have the largest selection I have ever seen and singles are no problem. And I was even able to find a number of new brewers there, which is especially exciting. So no surprise, my latest list of new brewers is dominated by offerings from Luke's. Check it out if you are ever in the area, as well as any of the other fine stores on that list.

Mad River Steelhead Extra Pale Ale
Bottle -- Kappy's, Malden
my first beer from mad river -- a few local stores recently started carrying this california brewer. cloudy, golden... malty aroma... citrus hops... very sessionable.
Score: 7

Oxford Hefeweizen
Bottle -- Luke's, Rockland
bavarian style unfiltered. aroma and taste of wheat/yeast. not especially good.
Score: 4

Riverhorse Tripel Horse
Bottle -- Luke's, Rockland
golden pink in appearance... fruit in aroma and taste... apple champagne really, and quite sweet. not exactly a sophisticated tripel, but not bad.
Score: 6

Two Brothers The Bitter End
Bottle -- Luke's, Rockland
a pale ale from illinois. overly carbonated out of bottle... sweet, malty aroma... mild grassy hops in taste, with slight tanginess... not bad.
Score: 7

Best New Brewer:
Speakeasy Prohibition Ale
Bottle -- Luke's, Rockland
nice fresh aroma of hops. taste of caramel and floral hops. well balanced. cool bottle. i am impressed.
Score: 9

A weekend of Maine beers

First off, sorry for the unannounced break in posts. I haven't been drinking quite as many beers lately and I suppose this is becoming more of a chore. That said, I have been keeping up with my notes and intend to keep logging everything I drink on the blog. Just please bear with me as the posts come in fits and starts.

Columbus Day weekend was spent up in Maine with my family and on the way Kelly and I stopped at Florian's Market in Auburn, Maine. This was really just a conveniance store, but what a great selection of Maine beers. Here was our take.

Black Bear Pail Ale
750 ml -- Florian's Market, Auburn, ME
my first beer from this brewpub in orono, maine. fruity, sweet hops in aroma. lingering, unpleasant taste though. probably more enjoyable before a umaine hockey game though.
Score: 5

Oak Pond Nut Brown Ale
750 ml -- Florian's Market
mahogany in color... taste of sweet, light hops, brown sugar, malts... lively and smooth on palate. by far my favorite, of the three oak pond beers i tried.
Score: 8

Oak Pond Oktoberfest
750 ml -- Florian's Market
sparkling orange in glass... fairly bland cereal malts in aroma, sweet tasting... drinkable, but a pretty unexciting oktoberfest.
Score: 6

Oak Pond Pale Ale
Growler -- Florian's Market
light pinkish-orange... floral overtones, but mostly diacetyl (a buttery sensation relating to some problem with the yeast)... watery with very few hops in the taste... this really tastes like a pilsner, specifically, rolling rock.
Score: 4

My favorite:
Bar Harbor Acadia Pale Ale
Bottle -- Florian's Market
copper appearance... tasty, bitter citrus hops dominate throughout here... tasty malts to balance it out though... a hoppy pale for sure... dry and easy drinking... very good. shows me that bar harbor is about more than just their cadillac mtn stout.
Score: 9